The Vrinda project 

Script

The Vrinda project    index-                           

Documentary Script Episodes

The Vrinda Handbook

ssues
Projects
Backstage

Pundits
MDGs presentations
Countries presentations

 

 

Episode 4 - MDG 4 Reduce child mortality

 

Issue 2:  
NGOs as development actors: their role, their limits; their challenges

 

in

out

Video

audio

in

out

To be recorded

 

Backstage

Stefano asks  e Vrinda replies

 

 

To be recorded

 

MDGs - EPISODE 4

 

MDGs - EPISODE 4

 

 Goal 4: Reduce child mortality

 

Each year, millions of children die due to lack of hygiene and exclusion from health services.

The number of children dying in the poorest countries of the world is nearly 50 times higher than those dying in developed countries. In a world that has so many resources and means, to allow such massacre to take place is unacceptable.

The MDG 4 aims at lowering child mortality rates. This means to expand care services and address all child health determinants.

In the world now, majority of the children get vaccinated and indeed the child mortality rates are falling but in sub-Saharan Africa, one in seven children still do not live to see their fifth birthday.

There are still countries like Sierra Leone where governments are unable to provide free primary health services and where the presence of international non-government medical organisations is indispensable for saving lives.

 

 

 

 

Vrinda explains the difference between humanitarian help and development aid

 Kinds of development aid -  Humanitarian aid

 

 

    P. Krishna is the Rector of the Krishnamurti Foundation India, Varanasi.  

 

   
    Dilip Kumar is the Founder Member of Pravah

 

   

 

 

Sierra Leone - Emergency Surgical Hospital - Goderich 

One in eight women in Sierra Leone dies in childbirth as opposed to one in four thousand in developed countries. Infant mortality rates at 140 per 1000 births and under-five mortality rates at 286 per 1000 are still the highest in the world.  Considering that 49% of the total population of Sierra Leone is under the age of 18 and that the situation of the 2.3 million children living in Sierra Leone is still precarious, the national government faces a major challenge.

 

A country that once boasted of some of the best medical and nursing colleges in West Africa, today Sierra Leone’s public universities and hospitals are underfunded and lack basic facilities. Out of 13 districts in Sierra Leone, only 7 offer basic health care. Although staying in public hospitals does not cost, the government does not have sufficient funds to cover fees for treatments, medicines, operations and doctors. This means that poor people cannot afford treatments and other medical services. Sometimes, even minor problems, like fractures, can degenerate into serious and irreversible deformities.

 

As part of its efforts to rebuild its devastated health care system, in 2009, the Sierra Leonean government introduced free medical healthcare for pregnant women, breast-feeding mothers, and children under-five years. And in order to motivate health workers across the country, the government gave a six-fold increase in their pay packages.

 

Many international organisations support the local health care system by establishing clinics, hospitals, equipping existing public health care centres. Emergency is one such Italian non-government organisation that, along with other organisations like Marie Stopes, International Medical Corps, provides free health care services to the Sierra Leonean people, especially to victims of war and poverty and cases requiring surgery.

 

Emergency has been active in Sierra Leone since 2001 when it built a surgical hospital for war victims in Goderich, a village in a suburb of Freetown, the country's capital. Later, it also started admitting orthopaedic patients and surgical emergencies. In order to respond to the steeply rising infant mortality rates in the country, Emergency, in 2002, built a Paediatric Outpatient Department next to the hospital. This department provides treatment for illnesses like malaria (the leading cause of death of children under age 5), anaemia, and respiratory infections. Emergency’s paediatric clinic also organises health and hygiene education programmes as part of its preventive care measures. Along with an Italian university, Emergency has also developed a new protein rich food for malnourished children made with ingredients easily available in Sierra Leone.

 

With the vaccination coverage in the country being 76% for measles and 63% for DPT, infant mortality rates in Sierra Leone have now decreased to 76.6. per 1000 live births. The political will of the country and the funding contribution from international agencies like DFID, ADB, World Bank, UNFPA, and UNICEF to the “Free Health Care” policy of the government have been major determinants of the success of the policy.

 

 

 

 

 

Collecting the funds for the projects

 

To be recorded

 

 

 

Africa - Family Homes Movement (Father Berton)

 Africa - Family Homes Movement (Father Berton)

 

 

 

 

Spontaneous assistance and Organized cooperation

 

 India - NGO - Julian Parr

 

1 - Importance of NGOs, their Challenges and Limitations

 

Do you think we need NGOs to support development activities around the world?

A robust civil society is hugely important in terms of democratization and hearing the voice of people. For civil society has a more inclusive definition which is not just NGOs but also Media. The freedom of press in India it's is major strength... and if you suppress the freedom of Media you suppress development. 

What are their Challenges? 

NGOs are having the define their role in a new world order, especially international NGOs. What is are role now? We cannot continue to deliver services, for in doing so they undermine the role of the Government in doing that. My own sense it that we are now moving more towards advocacy and policies and that it the role we should be playing... we should be arguing to governments like India that you should put more than just 1% of the GDP into health.

What are their Challenges? 

Is whether they have an authentic voice. NGOs are very good in claiming to speak on behalf of people but they are not democratic institutions in their own right.

I can say that, yes, we have some very robust programs on the ground, but that is because I am saying it... if I had the same response from Coca-Cola, BP, Shell or even the government, I will be very sceptical of those figures and statistics. If we are going to hold other stakeholders and other sectors into account then we ourselves have to be much more transparent and honest about our own structure.

 

 

    Manoj Kumar  Country Director of Concern Worldwide 
  • NGO role and challenges

  • Feedback to donors:   Sometimes the donors should be more flexible, because the contest in Sierra Leone  is a very dynamic contest and they should respect the local contest and the local reality. Donors also need to give a sufficient time to aloud the community processes, to bring the changes which are long lasting and not just a quick change and when the donors support ended those changes collapse. 

 

   

 

 

EU days in Syria

 

 

 

 

 

Syria - Moving Hopes - Damascus

We meandered along the roads of Hajar al-Aswad, a poor southern suburb of Damascus, and home to many refugees, searching for a centre for physically challenged children established by an Italian non-government organisation called Armadilla.

 

Hajar al-Aswad is a poor neighbourhood that became home for Palestinian refugee families and then for Syrians from the Golan heights seeking refuge following the six-day war with Israel in 1967. The neighbourhood is also home to Syrian migrants from the rural areas as well as Kurdish people from the Northern villages of Syria, Turkmen communities and Iraqi refugees. Earnings from unskilled labour are the basis of family incomes.

 

We finally found the centre for children, established by Armadilla in cooperation with a Syrian woman’s organisation, called Zahret Al Mada’en where children suffering from neurological disorders are treated. The initial funds for building this centre were provided by an Italian Foundation specializing in child neuropathology,

 

Today, the centre provides diagnostic and physiotherapy services for more than 200 children of Hajar al-Aswad. Volunteers from Italian universities regularly come to this centre for treating the children and teaching new techniques to the Syrian physiotherapists. The organisations also organise meetings and events to raise awareness among the local people on the importance of diagnosing and treating neurological disorders early in children. The centre has now also become a space where women meet and discuss issues dear to their hearts, where they learn new skills and produce handicrafts, embroidered garments to earn some additional income for the families.

 

The success achieved by this small cooperation initiative among two development organisations in Hajar al-Aswad not only attracted the attention of international donor agencies but also the support of the Syrian Ministry for Health. A Syrian doctor from the state health care system regularly visits the centre, diagnoses and treats children and also trains the local physiotherapy assistants. And the European Commission has provided funds for establishing a sewing and embroidery unit that conducts skills training for women, helps them start micro businesses and links them to the markets and end users of the products they produce in this centre. Seeing the impact of this centre on the lives of families living in the neighbourhood, an Italian women’s organisation offered its support to establish a Women’s Resource Centre and provide technical support on designing and business linkages in Italy for marketing the products that women are producing.

 

In a conflict ravaged Syria with virtually inexistent tourism, the women of Hajar al-Aswad are struggling to market these traditional handicrafts. In this tough moment of Syrian history when international aid has been suspended and the economy is shattered, the Italian and the Syrian organisation continue to provide support to the women of Hajar al-Aswad, to assist their children and to sell their products in Armadilla’s fair trade shop in Rome.

 

Even if the impact of their work is limited in the midst of the political turmoil in Syria, it is the efforts of organisations such as these and their committed staff that keep alive the hopes of families in Hajar al-Aswad and show them that the world cares.

 

 

 

 

 

More reflections on  media and  public support

 

 

 

 

 

Brancatella alla RAI a Roma

 

 

 

 

 

TV7 on Sierra Leone

 

 

 

 

 

Comments on the TV7 seen

On the Armadilla studio

 

 

 

 

  Development Education

http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB097C4336B498D7E

 

Select the right passages

 

·         Finland - NGO - Rilli Lappalaine (video)  Lappalainen - Etikwa Ikutu -talking of disaster but not on prevention

·         Finland - NGO - Rilli Lappalaine (video)  - Media (and ONGs) stereotypes and the resulting disinformation

·        Finland - NGO - Rilli Lappalaine (video) - Media (and ONGs) media uninterested on the real policy issues – why?

 

 

 

 

 

The Vrinda project approach:  keeping the plurality of the points of view without establishing a final “truth”.  Is it possible in television?  Is it better done with the Web media?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
Testimonials
Zulfiquar Haider is the National Programme Coordinator for the Planning Commission (GoI) - UN, Joint Programme on Convergence. He was interviewed in Delhi on the 13th of April 2010 by Fausto Aarya De Santis

In Afghanistan there was a project called NSP (national solidarity project). The interesting things i found was that (1) it was something in the agenda of the government itself, (2) donors without wanting their flags and identity is publicized were ready to back it up and (3) unlike many other projects, this project was a lot more flexible in design, it allowed a degree of flexibility for the project to evolve.

The government saw all the local and international organizations as partners so there was a lot of space for dialogue which was created; so realities from the ground as implementation happened were feeding in the design aspect of the program... which changed, in many significant ways.   Instead of saying what will happen in the name of development, this project was building on creating local government councils and these councils would then make plans in a participatory way. Their development plans would determine what happens. Yes there was technical support given on budget, questioning who the beneficiary were and help people prioritize... but it was the people's plans and inspirations which were finding space.

Image:Media.png

see full interview:  http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL77195325F4994608

 

 
 
Testimonials
Olivier Consolo is the Director of CONCORD, an European NGO confederation for Relief and Development. He was interviewed by Vrinda Dar and Stefano De Santis in June 2011 in Brussels, Belgium
Image:Media.png

see full interview:   http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL9D696DEFD5A5F5F7